First off, any QB would take Tomlinson and Gates, and McCardell is a nice compliment.
And in response to your other QB's...
P Manning - Obviously 🙂
T Brday - OK, but that team is on the way down and he is losing weapons. Their defense isn't what it used to be, which lowers his value as an intimidation factor because teams can just score on them that much easier
D Bledsow - Please, this is Bledsoe. He will probably pass for 3000-4000 yards, but his TD to INT ratio will suck
M Hasselbeck - OK, I'll give you that one
C Palmer - Really has to be seen. He's so messed up in the head right now worrying and thinking about his knee. Once he gets over that, he'll be set. I think he's going to miss week 1 as well.
E Manning - Even if he starts strong he wont finish that way
B Favre - NO Chance
T Green - His value went WAY down when Roaf retired. When Roaf was hurt last year T. Gonzalez spent more time on the O-Line than catching passes. Trent Green was passing for less than 200 yards a game and barly had a TD each game. We will see how they replace Roaf
M Bulger - Maybe, but I think he's been blessed with good weapons over his career. Steven Jackson is no Marshall Faulk, and his receiving core is getting older so they are no longer the "Fastest Show on Turf"
D McNabb - Skeptical, but I think he'll be huge this year. Too early to tell realy as he will pretty much have to do it on his own.
D Culpepper - Have to wait and see really. Recovering from knee surgery, new team, new city, new system and coach
J Delhome - Great QB, not great for fantasy stats. His yards and TD per game are not consistent
J Plummer - Too prone for mistakes
D Brees - New Orleans Sucks - enough said.
K Warner - He won't even play past week 5, 6 or maybe 7 when Leinart comes in
A Brooks - No way, he sucks and no one can keep Randy Moss happy