Discussion in 'General Hardware' started by canadian_divx, May 29, 2003.
waht is the best HSF for an amd 2800+
you can get a 30 dallor volcano 11 xaser which is a REALLY good HSF or you can spend like 40 on an SLK 900 (just the sink) then buy a fan for it SLK-900 is prolly one of the best if not the best Heat sink out there right now but you don't get any of the bells and whistles of the thermaltake volcano 11 (variable fan speed back bracket speed ajuster and all that junk) I own a volcano 11 xaser and it can keep my 1800+ @ 1.93ghz with 333fsb at about 102 to 111 under full load and I've heard people with the SLK 900 have gotten 1700+ to about 2.3 or 2.4ghz with that @ about the same temp. (but this depends on where you live so remember that) I guess it all comes down to if you wanna spend 30 something for a good HSF or 40 + the cost of a fan on a really good one.
the HSF has to be under 100 canadian that is all i care for but i was reading about the SLK 900 and that means that i need to physicaly bend things on my mobo for it to fit and i dont like that idea,
try this on for size... I am getting it tomorrow and will be able to give you more info once I do
i have herd very bad things about thoes, they may look cool but not practical
32 bucks sazar haha you should have gotten a thermal take for that much.
It looks cool ive seen them in those mini-itx computers but I don't know how well they perform.
hmm... well I guess I will have to check it out farther than..
btw I have a thermaltake @ the mo krux...
my m8 runs the zalman and his temps as well as case noise were quite low... so I was considering getting one...
go you! ive been a thermaltake fan (teehee get it?) since the volcano 6
can anyone link to a review of the zalman HSF... ?
I would love to check out the review before buying it...
there yah go
other than the weight... the thing I am getting seems to be pretty good...
the one you have is the 3100 model... I am getting the 6000 model which is a cooler design...
thanks for the link...
i am looking at the volcano 11 (dont care about noise) but i was just serfing around some sites and it seems pretty good for the heat but is there anything better than it becides electrothermic, water, slk900??
nope not really it can get noisy, I usally turn mine down b4 I go to sleep. but other then the volcano 11 there isn't really anything in its price range that is better. no If you want to spend 50 to 90 bucks for a HSF you can get one better but even those have peltiers on them whichs mean your gonna need one of those power plant cards or another PSU all together. you could get the SubZeroG4 by thermal take that comes with all that stuff but its about 120 bucks
and sazar you didn't say what model so I just put a link up for the first one I found
my link has the model number of 6000 listed... but the website has a review of that as well..
I just read through... highly recommended... cept its a heavy mofo...
almost 1/2 a kilo
here read this one
ohhh ok then disregaurd my last post
is the volcano 11 louder than the 9??? at full???
That HSF is 50% over the wight rating for the socket 7. On top of thta it only uses a single tab clip. Thats a formula for a fried CPU and MB.
A friend had his HSF shear off the plastic tab on the socket. In the seconds it took him to shutdown the system the CPU fired and the motherboard was overheated enough to destroy it.
Hope you use the zalman on an ASUS or SOLTEK. They're the only ones I know of with immediate thermal shutdown.
BTW the thermal resistance numbers look really good but you can never tell how they tested to get them. Tbred is smaller die and numbers are worse. bigger palomino or barton look much better.
Be interested to see how the Zalman works if you get it.
yes.. I was looking @ that... the other option I have is the 3100 which is half the weight.. ie... under the 300grm threshold specified... and it is only 1C warmer in tests conducted...
might as well just get that... it still runs in silent mode through athlon XP 2200+ I believe and seeing as I have a 1900+
it's a heavy one, but that doesn't really make a difference when it screws into the motherboard opposed to clipping on. as long as you have those mounting holes in your board, consider the swiftech. friend got it recently and his cpu temps dropped about 10°... he had a coolermaster hhc-001, which is a decent heatsink it it's own right.
slk-900u is supposed to be good too, but i haven't been able to play with one.