PCI or USB wireless card/adapter?

Discussion in 'General Hardware' started by Dr. Kramer, Dec 15, 2005.

  1. Dr. Kramer

    Dr. Kramer Who's Yo' Doctor?

    Messages:
    42
    So I'm looking at getting a wireless internet adapter / card for my desktop...but I'm sorta clueless on the benefits / drawbacks of the PCI card or the USB dongle.

    Which is better? which has stronger reception? Any help is very gladly appreciated...

    DK
     
  2. jpom

    jpom OSNN Addict

    Messages:
    166
    Personally I perfer USB type adapters such as the Linksys WUSB54G http://www.linksys.com/servlet/Sate...827517&pagename=Linksys/Common/VisitorWrapper

    I like these because they use a cable, so you can position them for best signal and they have a high gain anntanne so you get better signal. 2 things though, 1 you have to make sure you have USB 2.0, you can use them with 1.0 and 1.1 but I've found that they don't work anywhere near as well. If you don't have USB 2.0 I would suggest a PCI card. 2. These adapters draw power from the USB port, that shouldn't be an issue for desktops (it wasn't for me) but you might want to use a powered USB Hub, and I have found that laptops don't provide as much power through USB as Desktops, so if you use it on a laptop you might have issues.

    All I can say in the end is that I have noticed a serious increase in speed and connection strength after switching from a PCI Card Wireless Adapter to a USB Adapter. But that is just my experience.

    James
     
  3. kcnychief

    kcnychief █▄█ ▀█▄ █ Political User Folding Team

    Messages:
    16,948
    Location:
    Massachusetts
    I would like to campaign for the other side, as I have had better luck with PCI cards. Between the two devices from my experience, I think the more important factor to consider is interference. This includes, but is not limited to, 2.4Ghz wireless phones, some microwaves, old insulation, cement, etc.
     
  4. tom9042

    tom9042 OSNN Senior Addict Folding Team

    Messages:
    314
    Location:
    New Jersey
    I bought one of these when I had to move my wife's computer to another part of the house. Easy to install and works pretty good. I haven't tried a PCI card though.
     
  5. apu95

    apu95 Caffeine-->Code Converter

    Messages:
    502
    Location:
    Montreal, Canada
    Yeah, I've only used usb adapters and pcmcia...The usb adapter I have in my room (Dell Truemobile 1180, uses a prism2 chipset) isn't that bad. I really like the fact that you can position it to your liking, but on the other hand, you can always switch the antenna on a PCI adapter for a full positionable one as well ;)
     
  6. iceman7311

    iceman7311 OSNN Senior Addict

    Messages:
    311
    isn't the pci acutally faster and more stable?
     
  7. LeeJend

    LeeJend Moderator

    Messages:
    5,291
    Location:
    Fort Worth, TX
    I've played around with both and everybody who posted above is right. Even though they disagree...

    Pros and Cons:

    The PCI card is handicapped because the antenna sticks out the back which is usually shoved up against a wall blocking the wireless signal. The antenna swivel mount does allow orientation in different directions though which lets you position it for optimum signal reception. You have to dedicate a PCI slot for this one function which is a problem with slot limited microATX MBs. PCI cards readily support windsurfer antennas.

    The USB dongle has a smaller antenna so it is handicapped on signal strength also. You can move the dongle hub cable around to getthe best reception but you are always horizontally polarized (no swivel bracket) so if you are going from the first floor to the second floor of a house you will loose signal strength. There may also be issues with the usable share of bandwidth on your USB ports compared with a dedicated PCI card. I have not tried a windsurfer on my Dlink dongle. The geometry is wrong and the antenna too short, so I haven't made the effort.

    Final Solution:
    If you have a slot free use PCI card with an external gain boosting antenna. This configuration allows you to still add a windsurfer though the improvement may be marginal since the add on antenna is already directional to acheive the gain boost.
     

    Attached Files:

  8. Admiral Michael

    Admiral Michael Michaelsoft Systems CEO Folding Team

    I like a PCI approach with an separate antenna (like in the pic LeeJend posted). I'd rather have the antenna moveable then the whole unit. But that's me.
     
  9. dreamliner77

    dreamliner77 The Analog Kid

    Messages:
    4,702
    Location:
    Red Sox Nation
    PCI all the way. I had nothing but problems with USB.

    As is often said about cable modems, "USB is not for networking."
     
  10. Admiral Michael

    Admiral Michael Michaelsoft Systems CEO Folding Team

    LOL thats how I feel bout the USB NICs!
     
  11. hazmatt87

    hazmatt87 OSNN Junior Addict

    Messages:
    10
    USB is definately not for networking, but it happens that windows XP has native support for firewire networking, now all we need are some wireless dongles for firewire and we would be set. I really want to see more firewire being used, I have all these ports on my computer for firewire, but everything from cameras to cell phones i have are USB.
     
  12. Dr. Kramer

    Dr. Kramer Who's Yo' Doctor?

    Messages:
    42
    So I just got a Netgear WG311v3 for x-mas. Tried searching for some reviews online, but not many are out there.

    What is out there are lots of disgruntled people that have had lots of problems with this one.

    Anyone here have any experience with this adapter? Or any PCI adapters that they can recommend?

    DK
     
  13. LeeJend

    LeeJend Moderator

    Messages:
    5,291
    Location:
    Fort Worth, TX
    PCI wirelaess cards are so cheap they are pretty much throw aways. The only problems I've seen with throw away wifi is the signal range may be less than desired.

    Try it in your location and see how it works. Turn on cellphones, microwaves, washing machines that will be in or near the signal path to see if they degrade range.

    The other annoyance may be if they require special install software instead of the default Windows wifi drivers. This is only an annoyance. Not really a performance issue.

    PS You are running Windows right? There are a mess of "linux driver" posts on that card.
     
  14. jcim05

    jcim05 OSNN Junior Addict

    Messages:
    35
    Location:
    Connecticut
    I have always used a PCI card and had no problems with it until we put up a new wall in my house. The wiring must have bounced the signal or something, so I went out and bought a lynksys USB adapter. With a longer cable I was able to place the antenna where it would get a strong signal.

    USB all the way!!
     
  15. dreamliner77

    dreamliner77 The Analog Kid

    Messages:
    4,702
    Location:
    Red Sox Nation
    YOu could always get an extension antenna for the PCI card. I have one now and it works great.