Help me help my friend... choosing Video Card.

Discussion in 'General Hardware' started by Blade195, Aug 9, 2004.

  1. Blade195

    Blade195 OSNN Addict

    Messages:
    111
    Using the upgrade for 5 months for Doom 3, Half-life 2, and Sims 2. And then he is off to the army. This is quite a tricky question so I couldn't recommend him right away.

    The cheapest Radeon 9800 Pro is $258 (US) here, so that is out of his budget.

    Geforce FX 5900 XT . . . $193 (plus a $26 350W PSU)

    Radeon 9600 XT . . . . . .$150 (plus a $18 300W PSU)

    So he does not want to go overboard. He just wants to have a card that will be good enough for the 5 months. No more, no less. What is the best choice to make.

    Thanx for your help, as usual...
     
  2. logisticprism

    logisticprism Time Dr. Freeman?

    Messages:
    203
    how well do you need to run those games? either of them can run on a 9600xt or 5700 ultra decently well for not too bad of a price. doom 3 can go 1024x768 medium quality at pretty decent speeds on a 5700 ultra. he doesn't need a super powerhouse graphics card if it's only for a couple of months. granted it won't be the fastest or smoothest thing in the world, but it certainly is a cheap option. and the new PSU thing? get some good stable, reliable power from either an antec, enermax, or TTGI power supply, don't buy the 18 dollar noname crap, trust me you'll be much happier.
     
  3. Blade195

    Blade195 OSNN Addict

    Messages:
    111
    Well, i was talking about the 5900 XT instead of the 5700 Ultra. Since they cost almost the same, and you seem to be recommending the 5700 Ultra, I guess i'll tell my friend to go with the 5900 XT. Afterall, the 5900 XT is a bit better than the 5700 Ultra.

    What about the Radeon 9600 XT? if that can run Doom 3 on med 1024 x 768, then i guess that'd be better since it is cheaper.
     
  4. logisticprism

    logisticprism Time Dr. Freeman?

    Messages:
    203
    this article will answer all your performance questions.
    http://www2.hardocp.com/article.html?art=NjQ0LDY=

    it's long, but it's good. the benchmarks are pretty accurate, although i dothink that the cards can do a little bit more than what they say on hard ocp
     
  5. the_music_man

    the_music_man aka prodj88 =P

    Messages:
    2,401
    Location:
    USA
    i have thet 9600 xt and it runs a little choppy on doom sometimes even with 800 x 600 but with halo and counterstrike it runs flawless
     
  6. the_music_man

    the_music_man aka prodj88 =P

    Messages:
    2,401
    Location:
    USA
    btw someone move this to gfx card thread