Ati or N-Vidia Graphic Card

Discussion in 'Graphics Cards' started by neo, Nov 21, 2002.

  1. neo

    neo Guest

    I am thinking of buying a graphic card. I am really confused which one to buy.

    Ati's Radeon 9700 Pro 128Mb
    OR
    N-Vidia GeForce FX 128Mb.
     
  2. chastity

    chastity Moderator Political User

    Messages:
    2,273
    Location:
    Arizona near the Grand Canyon
    Well based on the choices you posted the question is how soon do you want a new graphics/video card? That said at the moment the ATi card is the king of the hill but that could change in the blink of an eye but if you want the best at the present time go ATi if can wait then maybe go Nvidia.
     
  3. Zedric

    Zedric NTFS Guru Folding Team

    Messages:
    4,006
    Location:
    Sweden
    GeForce FX isn't out yet (is it?). But it seems it'll whoop some a$$ when it does come out. :)
     
  4. neo

    neo Guest

    N-vidia will be out in 3rd week of feb '03 or 1st week of march '03
    I am willing to wait for it, As much as I know about Ge-Force FX It's going to Kick A** of Ati radeon 9700 Pro. I like ati but I am having some problem with the drivers for radeon 8500le. And I was waiting for a new card for a long time. As for the price first n-vidia might sell for aroung $499 or so but it's going to drop to $369.
     
  5. FoSsiL

    FoSsiL Guest

    if i were you i go for the cheaper one, the ati. the performance isnt that big but the price range is.
     
  6. Sazar

    Sazar F@H - Is it in you? Staff Member Political User Folding Team

    Messages:
    14,905
    Location:
    Between Austin and Tampa
    :) all answered already really... when do you want the card/how much are you willing to spend/what are you going to do with the card...

    GF FX won't be out for a while... its SPECS outperform everything else.. but at the moment it is all on paper...

    the 9700pro is excellent and is present now... however may not meet the potential standards of the GF FX... there is a r300 refresh expected next quarter... that should compete well with the GF FX...

    so as you see you have many choices... also give the Xabre 600.. the new card from SiS a decko.... seems decent enough...

    if you need top of the line NOW... get the 9700pro... else wait for the new stuff from ATi and nvidia next year...
     
  7. Zedric

    Zedric NTFS Guru Folding Team

    Messages:
    4,006
    Location:
    Sweden
  8. JSC2k03

    JSC2k03 Guest

    ATI Radeon 9700 Pro rule

    If I were you, I would buy ATI Radeon 9700 Pro and not buy Nvidia GeForce FX .... because it will probably go bad after a month or year so on. Everytime Nvidia comes out with new graphic card...ATI always answer back with a powerful one. By looking at the pics of Nvidia, its almost look the same as the Radeon, so to me I don't see any difference in the FX and the 9700 Pro..Beside if u have the 9700 Pro, your can trade it in for a cheaper price the the new ATI graphic card comes out.
     
  9. Jz1397-5

    Jz1397-5 XP Bad Ass

    Messages:
    1,278
    Location:
    Philadelphia PA
    if you want it right now, get the 9700 pro, you can get it for 320 on newegg. Nvidia will come out, but their prices will be high at the start to you will have to wait a little longer for them to come out. if you do not care on what company and you want something fast and powerful now, 9700 is the way to go
     
  10. Joe

    Joe Guest

    I depends on when you want it(just as everyone has said). From what I have heard is that they will be available in limited quantities in january. As of now the ATI 9700pro is the best. When the GeForce FX comes out it will the best. If I had the money to buy a card I would wait for the FX, or NV35(FX2?) depending on when it comes out in relation to the release date of DOOM 3. I am not sure about the next ATI card. If it's just a speed bump then no, if more features, etc. are added to make it more competitive then I would take a look at it.

    Hope you will be happy with your choice.
    Joe
     
  11. Sazar

    Sazar F@H - Is it in you? Staff Member Political User Folding Team

    Messages:
    14,905
    Location:
    Between Austin and Tampa

    I disagree Zedric... those benches other than perhaps the 4600's scores is nothing but paper... no one has independently conducted any of the tests and verified them...

    on the other hand it is very possible that the performance attributed to the GF FX by the article is accurate.. but untill the card debuts (in february mainstream) it is not prudent to say those figures are what we should go by...

    if you want to quote figures released by nvidia.. :) here is their competitions take on the product just released

    source : FiringSquad

    basically what I am saying is that nvidia and ati both have very decent competing products NOW and through february... and at varying price ranges... you can purchase those products now and newer products will be introduced this month (the xabre 600/ nvidia ti4600 with 8x agp supprt - called ti4800) and next month (with the 9500/9500pro/9700 radeon cards)... all in different price ranges..

    its a good time to be a consumer..

    now getting back to the GF FX.. the card is claiming a large perfromance delta over the 9700pro and looking at the hardware it is highly likely that the card should at LEAST be 15%-25% faster... based on nvidia documents... hoefully the hammer and the new gen pentium processors and the new nforce2/granite bay mobo's will reduce the bottlenecks that todays video cards suffer in current hardware... most of todays video cards (from the gf4 ti series and the older radeon cards, the 8500's series) are still somewhat bottlenecked by todays hardware...

    I fully do recommend going future proof and getting products that support dx9 though.. :)
     
  12. chastity

    chastity Moderator Political User

    Messages:
    2,273
    Location:
    Arizona near the Grand Canyon
    Well as to which card is better only time will tell. Now since you said your having trouble with drivers for an ATi card then I might wait till the GeForce FX hits the market since everybody says Nvidia driver support is very good. The final choice is yours to make Neo but I would do as much research on both cards before I make a decision.
     
  13. Galidon

    Galidon Guest

    My $.02.

    ATI Radeon 9700 pro. List US$399, web price around US$350ish, available now, best numbers in tests.

    nVidia GeForce FX 5800 ultra. Estimated List US$599, unknown web price, available approx Feb 2003(?), and boasts 30-40% better performance than the ATI.

    I guess it boils down to if you want to shell out US$600 for a video card in a few months for the biggest card out there, or settle for the beat that ther is currently now. Seems every 6-9 months each company is one upping the other.

    You can play favorite brand game or the latest tech game. All personal preference when you get right down to it. :shrug:

    Either would be a good choice.
     
  14. Sazar

    Sazar F@H - Is it in you? Staff Member Political User Folding Team

    Messages:
    14,905
    Location:
    Between Austin and Tampa
    if you have any problems with ati video cards.. a very good tech support site for it is www.rage3d.com most problems you face can be solved by the information provided there..

    latest information on GF FX does not look good for those waiting..

    full artice here... Cnet.com news

    now per nvidia there will be a few cards marked @ premium being offered over the christmas break... more info will come along as it is provided... other than that... everything else is speculation.. if you want a 2nd tier next-gen card... wait for a few months m8... your video card can play anything that is out there now... if there are driver problems... they can be solved...

    check out the forums I listed above or else post your problems in another thread with a proper heading and you will get help..
     
  15. Burpster

    Burpster Guest

    i wouldnt buy anything now...wait til after the Xmas rush
     
  16. neo

    neo Guest

    I decided to wait for FX to come out and see the spec and bM and then buy. I will mostly go for ATI since I did't have any problems with the agp card I bought (Rage fury Pro, TVwonder VE).
     
  17. Winter

    Winter OSNN Addict

    Messages:
    72
    Just get a GeForce 4Ti... as long as you have a fast processor, you won't need more than that for awhile... game companies aren't going to make games that 90% of the people can't play...
     
  18. Jz1397-5

    Jz1397-5 XP Bad Ass

    Messages:
    1,278
    Location:
    Philadelphia PA
    but i think he wants the best out there. also with the fastest out there the detail settings can be turned up high in the most recent games, so it does have some payoff
     
  19. Sazar

    Sazar F@H - Is it in you? Staff Member Political User Folding Team

    Messages:
    14,905
    Location:
    Between Austin and Tampa
    yup would make a lot better sense to get something with the advanced shader instruction sets the dx9 cards offer...

    if you have no idea what I am talking about check out some of the ati demo's dx9 :)

    halo for the pc is supposed to incorporate some dx9 instructions as is dx2 from eidos...

    doom III is strictly a dx8 game far as I know therefore I doubt people with cards now should have a problem running that particular product...

    per the current release schedule :

    for nvidia the nv30/31/34 components SHOULD be released over the upcoming month or two..

    for ati the r350 and r400 components as well as rv versions will be released ... r350 will be released depending on the performance delta that the gf FX will have over the r300 core based 9700pro...

    please do not take this as saying nv31 and nv34 are better than teh nv30... they are basically marketed for the lower end gaming market and for laptops (basically cheaper to produce than the 10 layer pcb of the gf FX)

    I would also like to comment on what galidon stated... a 40-50% delta over and above that of the 9700pro...

    per the design of the gf FX if you have seen the architecture and the technology they are using it seems extremely unlikely that the gf FX will actually be able to scale THAT high... gddr II has limitations (as does ddr) and it cannot scale much above 500mhz... as of now it should scale to around 550mhz tops... but technologies/yields do improve and the card may be able to go beyond...

    a deta of around 15-25% should be what nvidia is aiming for but no hard info has come out on the web... with the clock speeds that nvidia is aiming for it is highly unlikely that their gf FX will do a parhelia though...

    NOTE : (nvidia's gun metal demo is NOT dx9)
     
  20. zoey

    zoey Guest

    Re: ATI Radeon 9700 Pro rule


    1. What do you mean go bad? Break, not true, I have been using them for about 6yrs no probs.

    2. well, ATI will answer back with a better card, and then Nvidia will answer back with a better card, I't a cycle, just like CPU's. So you can wait forever for the best card. Just think in 3 years we will be saying all these cards are crap! these are just my thoughts.