Maxtor drives



Man...Maxtor sucks!

I just had my HDD replaced for free after i got a S>M>A>R>T error after only 6 months.

Now my new Maxtor is failing after only 3 weeks!

Drive Health is already predicting its failure wheras my 2 year old 20Gb Western Digital HDD is perfectly fine.


I had the same thing, the smart disk failure, and you can't turn it off. But I am hoping this drive will last a bit longer.


yep maxtor sucks. I have one could not agree more. fixin to put western digital in.


OSNN Addict
Dec 21, 2001
I have nothing but Maxtors...they've been as reliable as anything else on the market. One is going on 7 years old, which is positively ancient in the computer terms. It's small, but it works fine as a backup. I just bought another Maxtor a few months ago and it's also doing well. Just my $.02 worth.

Bob S

Interesting, I use nothing but Maxtors. I build quite a few computers in the course of a year and generally support what I build. I've never had a Maxtor failure, but have had a few Western Digital failures.


Mar 13, 2004
I loved Maxtor HD so much.. It doesn't give me any prob.. but WD HD on my old PC s**ks. THe motor went kabooooom... and all my precious data are gone... from then i dun trust WD. :)


OSNN Veteran Addict
Mar 18, 2002
I gotta say, I have had no prob with either Maxtor or Western Digital, I use Maxtor as my Primary and Western Digital as a backup, but it is small and slow.

If we are going to get into HDD Manufacturer bashing then I have got to place IBM in the direct firing line, I had a IBM DTLA 307030, no end of problems it went bellyup a few times, recovered it using the IBM Drive Fitness Test, then finally last week it died on last time, the noises it was making, they really do let you know they arent happy.
I cant be bothered sending it back to IBM so anyone got any Hex-Star screw bits, I wanna take this thing apart and see if I can find how it was making the noises. I've kinda always wanted to see a Hard Drive internals myself. Play with them a bit, and learn their basic mode of operation, and things like that.
Dont direct me to any sites explaining how they work for me, I know how they work I want to see it and things like that.


Well if you got a maxtor before they merged with quantum(how ever you spell it lol) then you got a good hard drive. But ever since that merger their product sucks. They did the merger about a year ago, give or take a few months. The thing that pissed me off they put the quantum drives in Maxtor boxes! The utility disk won't work with it because it says it's not a Maxtor drive! The maxtor drive I have is actually a Quantum fireball hard drive. When I called them about this, they responded that a card was included in box saying that this was a quantum drive. I found it, but it's the princible of the thing. I bought a Maxtor, and thats what I expected to get. So their response was to send it back to them and they would replace it. and pay for shipping? Well, with out a hard drive my pc won't work, and how long is this gonna take? 4 weeks? What happens to my data? Back it up. Well to much trouble for me so you just lost a customer over a problem you caused. Well they did not seem to care so my next drive? not a Maxtor!!!


Confused and Bewildered
Feb 12, 2002
At the moment I've got two Maxtor 40 gigs doing a beautiful job...I love 'em....

But I've had a Maxtor go bad in the past. I've had a WD go bad in the past. I once had an IBM go bad. I once had shingles. I got over it.

Friend of Bill

What, me worry?
Apr 1, 2002
For ATA 100 go IBM GXP 120. Fastest ATA 100 on the market today with IBM patented power management, allowing for the coolest hard drive temperatures around as well!:D


Questions R me
Jan 3, 2002
To me it sounds like all HD's have weaknesses - I'm about to buy a Maxtor DiamondMax Plus D740X 80GB Fluid next week.. I've read a ton of tests and so far the IBM disks beats everyone on speed, but they are also by far the loudest - from the user test's I've read the Maxtor is the most stabile..


I've used Seagate, Western Digital, IBM, and Maxtor drives. I've watched the Seagate, WD, and IBM drives die. The Maxtor drives are as perfect as the first day I bought them. Heck, I still have an OLD 650 meg Maxtor drive in one of my systems and it is still going strong. I prefer Maxtor but to each their own.


hardware monkey
May 8, 2002
seems all major name brand harddrives are basically excellent. if one brand failed horribly compared to the others, it simply wouldn't be in business anymore.

some people i guess have bad luck with a certain brand sometimes... it could be a power supply issue, physical abuse, or just plain luck of the draw.

can't we all just get along?? :D

Members online

Latest profile posts

Perris Calderon wrote on Electronic Punk's profile.
Hey ep!

All good with me, applying for microsoft mvp right now, should have done this a while ago.

Notifications don't work, I only found your response by comming back to hunt up some threads, if you want, give me your email address so we can keep in touch easier, mine is perriscalderon at gmail
Perris Calderon wrote on Electronic Punk's profile.
Ep, glad to see you come back and tidy up...did want to ask a one day favor, I want to enhance my resume , was hoping you could make me administrator for a day, if so, take me right off since I won't be here to do anything, and don't know the slightest about the board, but it would be nice putting "served administrator osnn", if can do, THANKS

Been running around Quora lately, luv it there
Electronic Punk wrote on Perris Calderon's profile.
All good still mate?
Hello, is there anybody in there? Just nod if you can hear me ...

Forum statistics

Latest member