I don't see what was in those reviews that didn't make it to the final version of Doom 3. The hype was mostly on the graphics, and that it did deliver. Big name reviewers have also had access to pre-release versions of Doom 3 for a long time, so no, they did not get those early previews out without playing the game. The majority of the hype was centered around the graphics, and that they did deliver. id and the reviewers said that the game was not going to feature new and unique gameplay, and it didn't. I don't know of any professional reviewers that have actually said that Doom 3 was going to be the second coming of Jesus, and I've probably read every pre-release review of Doom 3 out there. What they did say was it is going to be a great game, and indeed it is for those whose cup of tea comes in the form shotguns and monsters.