Which is better??

Discussion in 'Windows Desktop Systems' started by ZipTriX, Feb 18, 2002.

  1. ZipTriX

    ZipTriX Guest

    Maxtor DiamondMax® Plus 60 or IBMDeskstar 120GXP??
  2. DrX

    DrX Guest

    Personally i would not go near an IBM drive, I have had nothing but problems with my IBM's... sent back 4 drives so far

    My maxtors are great i recommend them......
  3. JJB6486

    JJB6486 Retired Mod Political User

    West Lafayette, IN, USA
    I've never personally owned one, but I have heard IBMs have very crappy quality control, and they have a huge RMA rate.

    I am running Dual 40GB Maxtors in RAID in a server at work, running for 140 days without a hitch.

    I use Western Digitals in my home machine. They work great too.

  4. G-Money

    G-Money Big Air

    Springfield Mo
    IBM GXP Problems: The Truth Exposed and Possible Fixes
    Published: 12/02/2002
    Author: Cameron Wilmot

    For months now users of IBM manufactured hard disk drives based on the Deskstar 60GXP and 75GXP models have been experiencing substantial frequent fail rates and data loss – Cameron "Mr.Tweak" Wilmot recently fell victim himself and suggsts what the problem may be, and possible solutions!

    more----> http://www.tweaktown.com/document.php?dType=article&dId=180

  5. ZipTriX

    ZipTriX Guest

    Thank you!! I was thinking highly about IBM, then saw the new Maxtors. Currently I have Western Digitals, and well this will be the second time replacing them within a year. Thank you for saving me a headache of going through crappy hard drives.
  6. eGoalter

    eGoalter Guest

    maxtor.all the way

    its a well known fact that maxtor are the best, and most reliable.
    thats all i have ever used i have never had 1 problem,unless you count the time i tried to shove one in a cramped floppy bay. that was my bad......lol:D
  7. scriptasylum

    scriptasylum Moderator

    Des Moines,IA
    My IBM just crapped out on me the other day. Actually it "developed" a bad cluster, but now I don't trust it. With my luck the next bad cluster will appear on the most important piece of data on my drive. :mad:

    This kinda sucks too because back when I bought it I did research to find the best preformance/reliability drive on the market (that wasn't SCSI).

    Well, I just got a Maxtor 80G so I'll see how that works for me.
  8. da rock

    da rock Guest

    i've been using maxtor hd's for awhile and never encountered
    a prob yet!