Where Vista Fails

Discussion in 'Windows Desktop Systems' started by napalmnthemorning, Apr 21, 2006.

  1. napalmnthemorning

    napalmnthemorning Moderator

    Messages:
    721
    Location:
    OREGON
    --Paul Thurrott
    April 19, 2006

    Wow! Paul really opens up on Vista in this article. A little surprised but we've all tested this thing. I guess it reminds me of when Toto pulls back the curtain in the wizard of oz to see the king pulling the handles to make the great and powerful Oz talk.

    Windows Vista February 2006 CTP (Build 5308/5342) Review, Part 5: Where Vista Fails

    " Promises were made. Excitement was generated. None of it, as it turns out, was worth a damn. From a technical standpoint, the version of Windows Vista we will receive is a sad shell of its former self, a shadow. One might still call it a major Windows release. I will, for various reasons. The kernel was rewritten. The graphics subsystem is substantially improved, if a little obviously modeled after that in Mac OS X. Heck, half of the features of Windows Vista seem to have been lifted from Apple's marketing materials.

    Shame on you, Microsoft. Shame on you, but not just for not doing better. We expect you to copy Apple, just as Apple (and Linux) in its turn copies you. But we do not and should not expect to be promised the world, only to be given a warmed over copy of Mac OS X Tiger in return. Windows Vista is a disappointment. There is no way to sugarcoat that very real truth. "
     
  2. kcnychief

    kcnychief █▄█ ▀█▄ █ Political User Folding Team

    Messages:
    16,948
    Location:
    Massachusetts
    I read that when it was posted, can't believe it was yesterday, seems like so long ago :s

    I was a bit shocked that Paul was so brutal with his honesty, but that is what makes him such a great writer :)
     
  3. napalmnthemorning

    napalmnthemorning Moderator

    Messages:
    721
    Location:
    OREGON
    Exactly kcnychief. Sort of took me for a loop. And since it was the great and powerful Paul Thurrott saying it made it even more suprising. I guess I'm just impressed to see someone who obviously has connections and ties to MS actually have to courage to speak up and make a constructive honest opinion and not be afraid of repercussions.
     
  4. NetRyder

    NetRyder Tech Junkie Folding Team

    Messages:
    13,256
    Location:
    New York City
    At least this write-up is better than his now infamous "Vista is a train-wreck" rant (which was followed by a "Vista is a guaranteed home run!" soon after). :D

    He makes some decent points and valid arguments, and there are some things I disagree with, but I think the conclusion brings out the point he's actually trying to make. It's not that Vista is bad in an absolute sense; it just never got to what the original vision was (I wouldn't call them promises, really).

     
  5. kcnychief

    kcnychief █▄█ ▀█▄ █ Political User Folding Team

    Messages:
    16,948
    Location:
    Massachusetts
    I think the real area where they failed is that they were talking/hyping the OS almost a full 4 years before it's eventual release :s

    Any team can talk about what they think they can do that far ahead of time. Sad part is if they delivered all features they promised, it wouldn't be as big of a deal. Now that they have pulled out and failed on others, that is where the scrutiny lies.
     
  6. j79zlr

    j79zlr Glaanies script monkey Political User

    Messages:
    2,725
    Location:
    Chicago
    LOL, MS has had what 5 years for this OS, they've pushed the release date back time and time again, and now the only real feature left that is worth upgrading for, UAP, is broken.

    I can't see anyone upgrading, atleast anyone in their right mind. I guess MS still has the new PC market.

    I actually find it really funny that you fanboi's are agreeing with him? [confused]
     
  7. Khayman

    Khayman I'm sorry Hal... Political User Folding Team

    Messages:
    5,518
    Location:
    England
    *Khaymans Summary*
    Ahem

    "WHINE WHINE WHINE WHINE WHINE"

    the end
     
  8. technokid88

    technokid88 Part of a System Folding Team

    Messages:
    741
    Location:
    In a world without windows
    Bad Microsoft lol.. thats this guys fav words
     
  9. pluto

    pluto OSNN Addict

    Messages:
    202

    He is concerned about the lack of a stupid assed game?

    This guy rants and raves about stuff and pretends to have something to say. But it just boils down to this:

    He is full of sh*t.

    Seriously. Ive always thought this about him. I cant read anything by him with out loosing interest and skipping to the parts which are relevant to the topic title. I had to skip a few paragraphs before I read anything remotely related to where Vista fails.

    As I say, he is full of sh*t. He cant write either. Theres very little content in what he says.
     
  10. Grandmaster

    Grandmaster Electronica Addict Political User Folding Team

    Messages:
    10,574
    Location:
    Santa Clara, CA
    Have you thought about the possibility that they maybe aren't fanboys?
     
  11. technokid88

    technokid88 Part of a System Folding Team

    Messages:
    741
    Location:
    In a world without windows
    I totally agree with you
     
  12. Sazar

    Sazar F@H - Is it in you? Staff Member Political User Folding Team

    Messages:
    14,905
    Location:
    Between Austin and Tampa
    I think that m$ has done well since '95.

    Namely win2k and xp have been decent releases (even though xp was a graphical re-hash of 2k).

    But yes, he does have valid points about WHY he says what he does about Vista.

    I mean come on people, he is absolutely right about the info.

    It's the same reaction I am having to sony and their gargantuan promises about the ps3 beign more powerful than R2-D2, only to find out it's more like a neutered AIBO without the cuteness.

    I still haven't gotten my invite for the beta thing ( :( ) but the info on the o/s out there, especially the graphical changes, are very nice.

    I do wish they will make the gui more easily changeable, rather than requiring hacks. A disclaimer in their EULA should handle potential risks from viruses/malware/attacks.
     
  13. NetRyder

    NetRyder Tech Junkie Folding Team

    Messages:
    13,256
    Location:
    New York City
    I think people are misunderstanding Paul's intentions. The anti-MS crowd is taking the whole thing out of context and making it sound like this is a big deal because Paul Thurrott called Vista a failure as a whole. He didn't. He's simply being balanced and pointing out the good and bad sides, just like any decent reviewer should. He's a little disappointed by the fact that Vista has not quite become what the original Longhorn project set out to do, and I don't think anyone can disagree with that.

    Come on, man. We're not part of the "OMG M$ sux!!" bandwagon, so we automatically become "fanboys" because there's nothing in between the two extremes, you know? </sarcasm> :D
     
    Last edited: Apr 21, 2006
  14. Mastershakes

    Mastershakes Moderator

    Messages:
    1,721
    Location:
    Montreal
    To add on to Net's comment, remember how long it took before XP was a rock solid OS? To me it's been relatively stable since I installed it in October 2002 - but it became real stable to me after SP2.

    I will expect the same from Vista, and on that note, IE7.
     
  15. Sazar

    Sazar F@H - Is it in you? Staff Member Political User Folding Team

    Messages:
    14,905
    Location:
    Between Austin and Tampa
    Net, we are an XP featured community or whatever. By default we are fanboi's :cool:

    Wrt XP being stable, I think the o/s was actually very stable. The issue was the lack of 3'rd party drivers (and windows driver list) for all the hardware out there. At least that was MY issue with XP when I first switched over.

    That's why I dual-booted with win2k and xp for almost a year before purging win2k.
     
  16. technokid88

    technokid88 Part of a System Folding Team

    Messages:
    741
    Location:
    In a world without windows
    When he wrote that article, he should of cut some of the BS out of it. When i was reading the first few paragraphs i was like what the hell is this: Then skipped to the other points. I think Vista wont be the all in wonder that MS hoped it would be. Actully MS is a big company and plans on growing, so they are not going to throw it all in one product, They will give everyone little at a time. Wait till the Vista 3000 comes out lol....
     
  17. Sazar

    Sazar F@H - Is it in you? Staff Member Political User Folding Team

    Messages:
    14,905
    Location:
    Between Austin and Tampa
    His point was that of all the things promised, many of the GOOD ones have been cut out to allow for delivery of the product on time. Sounds ludicrous since the o/s is sooo delayed already but c'est la vie.

    I don't buy your bit about m$ not putting it together with all the features it said it would coz it wants to introduce them later. That would make absolutely no business sense when it is trying to set itself up in a leadership position, technology-wise.
     
  18. technokid88

    technokid88 Part of a System Folding Team

    Messages:
    741
    Location:
    In a world without windows
    Well they already hold a leadership position. Example HP

    In the early 90's HP used to have technology to produce printers that printed very fast at very low prices. But they never put these prints into the market till the yr 2000.
     
  19. Sazar

    Sazar F@H - Is it in you? Staff Member Political User Folding Team

    Messages:
    14,905
    Location:
    Between Austin and Tampa
    You can't hold things back in the market today.

    It is VERY different from what it was in the 90's.

    HP btw still makes a substantial amount of it's margin from printers.
     
  20. technokid88

    technokid88 Part of a System Folding Team

    Messages:
    741
    Location:
    In a world without windows
    I know i dont agree with this, it is just my guess <you never know what big corporations are thinking>