SATA vs IDE DVD burners

Discussion in 'General Hardware' started by BouncingSoul, Jun 27, 2007.

  1. BouncingSoul

    BouncingSoul Stranger Than Fiction Political User

    Messages:
    1,297
    Location:
    Sioux Falls, SD
    I bought a Samsung SATA DVD drive to go with my new system. It didn't work, would only read certain media, no burned cd's but all burned DVD's. It was very weird. Anyways, I sent it back to Newegg and was looking for something else. But I go to thinking, I've already got a nice IDE DVD burner. Is SATA worth it? Both are cheap, I would assume SATA is slightly faster but I don't know. So that's the issue; Should I stick with my working IDE or get the SATA drive?
     
  2. LeeJend

    LeeJend Moderator

    Messages:
    5,291
    Location:
    Fort Worth, TX
    The speed of an optical drive is determined by the media, not by ide or sata interfaces.

    For optical drives the only advantage is cable clutter and not tying up limited ide ports you may have in a new system.

    As bluray and HD mature there may be an advantage going sata, but not for DVD and CDs.
     
    BouncingSoul likes this.
  3. BouncingSoul

    BouncingSoul Stranger Than Fiction Political User

    Messages:
    1,297
    Location:
    Sioux Falls, SD
    Once again you answer all my questions. Reps!
     
  4. dreamliner77

    dreamliner77 The Analog Kid

    Messages:
    4,702
    Location:
    Red Sox Nation
    Stick with IDE unless you have an overwhelming reason to move to SATA, the drive mechanics are the same with a different interface and there enough problems with SATA burners for me to stay away for a while.
     
  5. ray_gillespie

    ray_gillespie Moderator Staff Member Political User

    Messages:
    1,692
    Location:
    Birmingham, UK
    Though be careful that a lot of motherboard manufacturers are moving away from IDE completely now - I know you can use an adapter etc but it's extra hassle that you wouldn't get with a SATA.

    I still agree with the others, but thought you should know.
     
  6. ming

    ming OSNN Advanced

    Messages:
    4,252
    Location:
    UK
    I'm pretty sure every board will have at least 1 IDE socket for the coming yrs till BD/HD-DVD matures in the market. But I agree that one should beware of it being removed totally.
     
  7. Tuffgong4

    Tuffgong4 The Donger Need Food!!!! Political User

    Messages:
    2,465
    Location:
    Chicago
    I"m using a samsung SATA burner(ignore sig) without problems, I will not go back to IDE for anything just because my motherboard supports SATA natively out of the box. My main reason wasn't for speed or anything but for cable clutter, I have no ide cables running through my drive and makes things a lot tidier.

    Might be more a motherboard issue or bad samsung drive than anything. If you have a perfectly good ide dvd burner don't upgrade now. But if you need to get a new one get sata, they are about the same you may be able to go ide cable free!!!

    I got through burners about once every six months. (I burn a lot) and my drives break. I've had an NEC, Benq, samsung. All worked great and no coasters ever. Firmware updates are the best thing to do with a non functioning dvd burner before you rma or buy a new one.
     
  8. LeeJend

    LeeJend Moderator

    Messages:
    5,291
    Location:
    Fort Worth, TX

    Need Details! I had not heard this about the SATA burners. Links, sites to check, etc?
     
  9. Tuffgong4

    Tuffgong4 The Donger Need Food!!!! Political User

    Messages:
    2,465
    Location:
    Chicago
    Sata burners are really just a regular ide burner with a sata bridge, not sure if they've gotten to native sata yet.
     
  10. dreamliner77

    dreamliner77 The Analog Kid

    Messages:
    4,702
    Location:
    Red Sox Nation
    There are no native SATA burners yet.
     
  11. ShepsCrook

    ShepsCrook Red Sox Fan!

    Messages:
    1,489
    Location:
    Knightdale
    I bought the Plextor 716SA a long time ago, when it was $130. SATA and 16x looked and sounded really nice. It was nice not to have the IDE cable inside the case which made the system look cleaner, but overall, it didn't perform any better than the BenQ DW1620 that I ran on an IDE cable. In fact, I think the BenQ was better overall due to a wider range of compatibility with media, and it just seemed faster too.
     
  12. Tuffgong4

    Tuffgong4 The Donger Need Food!!!! Political User

    Messages:
    2,465
    Location:
    Chicago
    there is no performance benefit to going Sata, the only benefit is going to a better performing drive whether it's sata or ide.